January 23, 2019: Cultural Heritage Lender Requirements, Challenges, and Successful Implementation and Introduction to IAIA’s new Executive Director David Bancroft
After introducing David Bancroft, IAIA’s recently appointed Executive Director, three speakers shared their experience and knowledge on cultural heritage, a topic which hasn’t been covered in a recent WAB session:
Arlene Fleming, MA, MPS: Arlene is an archaeologist and specialist in cultural heritage documentation, conservation and management. She has served for two decades as consultant to the World Bank, advising on investment lending and safeguarding cultural heritage in Bank-financed projects. Her work has included authoring policy documents and reports, training Bank staff, consultants and clients, and serving as liaison between the Bank and cultural heritage organizations. She is founding co-chair of the IAIA Cultural Heritage Section.
Gregory Lockard, PhD: Greg is a professional anthropologist and cultural heritage specialist with training and experience in social work. From 2008 to 2010, he served as the lead cultural heritage specialist for the $3.8 billion PERU LNG Project, which involved the construction of a natural gas pipeline, liquefaction plant, and marine terminal in Peru. He currently works for the consultancy ERM, at which he serves as an environmental and social consultant managing and working on international projects, especially in Latin America and the United States. His work at ERM focuses on environmental and social impact assessments, environmental and social due diligence, and monitoring compliance with environmental, social, and cultural heritage lender requirements.
Christopher Polglase, MA, RPA: Chris is an archaeologist with nearly 40 years of professional experience in archaeological excavations, historical research, and applied cultural heritage studies. He directs Gray & Pape, Inc.’s Cultural Heritage Practice and has wide-ranging experience, having managed projects and conducted investigations throughout Europe and the Caucasus, the Continental United States and Alaska, Central America and Caribbean, and Africa. Mr. Polglase currently is Co-Chair of the Cultural Heritage Section of IAIA and a Technical Advisor for Leaders in Energy and Preservation. He also is part of a working group (along with Arlene Fleming) convened by ICCROM and IUCN to develop a tool kit and training related to cultural heritage and impact assessment as part of the World Heritage Leadership Programme.
Dear WAB Friends,
After a long summer break, we are starting off the Washington Area Branch (WAB) of the International Association for Impact Assessment (IAIA) with an informal happy hour on Tuesday, October 30th at the Taberna del Alaberdero (1776 I Street NW, the entrance is on 18th Street NW). People will trickle in 5:15 onwards. There is no reservation for WAB so first come, first seated! Everyone will pay their own way.
We look forward to catching up with you and to identifying potential speakers for upcoming sessions. As a start, we have interest for sessions to be organized on the following topics: legacy land issues and compensation, biodiversity, contractor management (including influx management). We now need to identify potential speakers for these topics – are you interested?? Are there other topics you’d like WAB to cover this year? Questions? Suggestions?
Our past events are posted on the WAB website, including presentation material provided by speakers: http://www.iaia.org/washington-area-branch.php
And of course, please check out the variety of impact assessment related resources available at www.iaia.org and also take the opportunity to renew memberships or join IAIA. You’ll also find information on the next annual conference – IAIA’19 in Brisbane, Australia.
We hope to see you at the Happy Hour on Tuesday. If you aren’t able to make the Happy Hour and are interested in sharing your experiences at a WAB session, please send Ariel and me an email.
All the best,
Ariel and Debra
Co-chairs, Washington Area Branch (WAB)
International Association for Impact Assessment (IAIA)
Dear WAB Friends,
We are delighted to announce our third session for 2018 from 3-5 pm on Wednesday, June 13th 2018:
International Financial Institutions (IFIs) provide financial support to development projects across the globe. Governed by standards that regulate environmental and social performance, these IFIs work with government and the private sector in difficult contexts where project impacts may result in unintended social and environmental harm. In response to growing demand for accountability and the need for impacted communities to access non-judicial recourse, IFIs has established independent accountability mechanisms (IAMs) mandated to receive complaints from communities. These complaints raise issues of environmental and social impacts and the IAMs use dispute resolution and/or compliance investigations to address these impacts.
Our speakers for this session include (links to biographies by clicking on their names and links to their respective organization’s website by clicking on the organization):
During this session, the speakers will:
Some guiding questions
Please RSVP by return email to Debra (email@example.com) and Ariel(Ariel.Cuschnir@mottmac.com) if you plan to attend to enable us to prepare appropriately. If you will attend, be sure to bring valid US government-issued identification. If you would like to participate, but cannot attend, please let us know so that we can provide WebEx connection details.
Other IAIA-related Announcements:
We hope you will join us on Wednesday June 13th 2018!
See you soon!!
Debra and Ariel
Co-chairs of the Washington Area Branch
WAB hosted its first session on the topic of use of security forces in private sector projects and the concept of fragility. Using Performance Standard 4 as the basis, the speakers shared some experiences on the requirements of companies to i) assess the security risk their operations may have or could create for communities; ii) develop ways to manage and mitigate these risks; iii) manage private security responsibly; iv) engage with public security; and v) consider and investigate allegations of unlawful acts by security personnel. Performance Standard 4 applies to companies of any size and in any country or sector. Discussion also included the Voluntary Principles on Security and Human Rights.
Wednesday, January 31, 2018 @ 3:00 pm Room U12-250
Coordinators: Ariel Cuschnir and Debra Zanewich
IAIA members can check out WAB on IAIAConnect.
Check out the latest happenings from the WAB below:
Biodiversity Monitoring: Challenges and Opportunities in Infrastructure Development Projects
Wednesday, September 20, 2017
This session focused on experiences shared by members of the Smithsonian Conservation Biology Institute’s Center for Conservation and Sustainability. Our speakers were:
They shared their experiences in designing and implementing biodiversity monitoring and assessment programs (BMAPs) with the oil and gas industry – see their presentation here [insert hotlink to the file “Smithsonian IAIA…”]. They provided examples from both terrestrial and marine environments. In these contexts, they used data from the BMAPs to respond to industrial environmental challenges, explored solutions that not only benefit biodiversity, but also fulfilled corporate mandates and account for the values of local communities and other stakeholders. The following case study documentation was shared by the speakers:
Developments in UK EIA Practice: Climate Change, Proportionate Assessment, and Professional Competence
Wednesday, August 23, 2017 @ 3:00 pm
This session will examine how UK Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) practice is rising to three key challenges posed by the 2014 amendment to the EU’s EIA Directive. It will focus on how UK practitioners are responding to the:
1. Need for enhanced consideration of climate change in EIA;
2. EU’s combined challenge of improving quality and streamlining assessment; and
3. Directive’s new expectation that EIAs are undertaken by competent experts.
IEMA EIA & Climate Change Principles documents circa 2010:
Construction Phase Challenges: Managing Labor Influx and Large Workforces
Wednesday May 24, 2017
The Washington Area Branch (WAB) of IAIA held its May 2017 meeting with two speakers sharing their experiences related to managing labor influx and large workforces. Approximately 25 people attended in person with another 15 participating via webex.
Qays Hamad– Qays is part of the Policy Compliance and Grievance Redress Operations Policy and Country Services Team at the World Bank. He is one of the lead authors of the World Bank's recent guidance note on Managing the Risks of Adverse Impacts on Communities from Temporary Project Induced Labor Influx http://pubdocs.worldbank.org/en/497851495202591233/Managing-Risk-of-Adverse-impact-from-project-labor-influx.pdf.
Qays spoke about identifying and managing potential impacts and risks from project induced labor influx, using as a case study some challenges the World Bank faced on a recent project in Uganda. Below is a link to the Inspection Panel Case Study for the Uganda Transport Sector Development Project. Through this link, all the Inspection Panel related documents can be found, including a link to the Influx Management Guidelines (see the list of documents on the bottom right corner).
This project highlighted the fact that the World Bank Safeguards and the contractor procurement process needs to be strongly interlinked. He provided the following figure to help assess potential impacts from labor influx:
Josefina Doumbia – is a Principal Environmental Specialist at the IFC. Josefina spoke about the challenges of managing workforce challenges associated with large mega-projects. She used as a case study the construction of a polypropylene complex in the State of Veracruz, Mexico. She focused on managing a large multicultural workforce, with many unskilled workers and a strong presence of unions. Despite these challenges, the project achieved high performance, using Health and Safety statistics as an key indicator. See her attached presentation.
Challenges in Resettlement: Case Studies
Wednesday, March 29th, 2017
Three speakers shared their experiences related to resettlement case studies:
Large Infrastructure Projects: Integrating Sustainability and Managing Risks
Wednesday, February 15, 2017
Three speakers shared their experiences related to integrating sustainability and managing risks in large infrastructure projects:
Davis, Rachel and Daniel M. Franks. 2014. "Costs of Company-Community Conflict in the Extractive Sector." Corporate Social Responsibility Initiative Report No. 66. Cambridge, MA: Harvard Kennedy School.
U.S. Treasury Views on Environmental/Social Risk Management at the Multilateral Development Banks (MDBs)
Wednesday, January 11th , 2017
Dan Peters, Director of the Office of Development Results and Accountability at the U.S. Department of Treasury, discussed the Treasury Department's role in the review and approval of MDB projects as well as Treasury's engagement with the MDBs on their environmental and social risk management policies. He also highlighted some emerging trends and challenges, followed by an exchange of insight and views by WAB members. His presentation is available here.
Cumulative Impact Assessment of Hydropower Development in Pakistan: A Case Study in a Critical Habitat in the Jhelum-Poonch Rivers Watershed
Wednesday, November 2nd , 2016
Pablo Cardinale, Principal Environmental Specialist at the International Finance Corporation (IFC) presented on IFC's approach to management of cumulative impacts potentially resulting from multiple cascading hydropower in critical aquatic habitat due to the presence of the CE Kashmir Catfish and the EN Golden Mahaseer, and how a project's Biodiversity Action Plan (BAP) has been elevated to guide a Biodiversity Strategy to manage potential cumulative impacts at a landscape level. His presentation is available here and the Cumulative Impact Assessment report is available here.
IFC Good Practice Handbook – Cumulative Impact Assessment and Management: Guidance for the Private Sector in Emerging Markets:
The Environmental and Social Framework of the Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank
Wednesday Sep. 28, 2016
Dear WAB Members and Friends,
Happy Autumn and welcome to the 2016-17 season of WAB Events.
We are pleased to announce that the first meeting of the Washington Area Branch (WAB) current season will address:
The Environmental and Social Framework of the Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank
Wednesday September 28th (3:00-5:00pm),
in Room U12-250
MIGA, World Bank U Building, 1800 G Street, NW
The presentation will be made by Stephen F. Lintner who is serving as the Senior Environmental and Social Advisor to the Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank. Stephen is a former President of the IAIA and was the Co-Chair of the Asia Day Forum held during our Annual Conference in Nagoya this May.
Although advance registration is not required for visitor’s entry to MIGA’s office (please bring valid government issued ID!), please RSVP by return email if you plan to attend so that we can prepare appropriately. We plan to broadcast the meeting live (but not record), so let us know if you need the WebEx access code.
Thank you for sharing this announcement with colleagues who may be interested in the topic.
We hope you will join us!
Will Knowland and Debra Zanewich
Climate Change and Impact Assessment, Wednesday May 4, 2016
For the first time in several years, the Washington Area Branch (WAB) returned to the key topic of Climate Change. Some three dozen IAIA-WAB members and friends participated in the two-hour session, which was convened at the offices of MIGA, and webcast to participants in several locations and countries. This meeting was a joint effort of WAB and the Climate Change Section, which, with 160 members, is IAIA’s on-going forum for IA practitioners to exchange expertise and knowledge on climate change across all areas of IA.
WAB, with IAIA and the World Bank, had organized a Special IAIA Symposium on Climate Change and Impact Assessment in November 2010. A year later, we devoted a session to updates from the Symposium and initial activities of IAIA’s Climate Change Section. But despite continued widespread interest, it has taken until now to again organize a session on the topic.
Meanwhile, the topic of climate change and impact assessment (CCIA) has become even more timely with recent Paris climate change agreement, and dedication of IAIA’s 2017 International Conference to the theme of Impact Assessment’s Contribution to The Global Efforts in Addressing Climate Change. In mid-May, just a week following our May 4th session, at IAIA 16 in Nagoya, Japan, the Climate Change Section would convene what has become an annual roundtable on the topic.
So the intention was to engage both the WAB membership and Washington-based development agencies, rekindle discussions begun at the Symposium in 2010, and begun building awareness and momentum for future efforts, including IAIA 17.
The First Announcement, Prospectus, Call for Session Proposals for IAIA 17 in Montreal is now posted on the web. See:
Impact Assessment’s Contribution to the Global Efforts in Addressing Climate Change
Le Centre Sheraton Montréal Hôtel
3-6 April 2017 http://conferences.iaia.org/2017/index.php
WAB members and friends are strongly encouraged to review the submission guidance and, if interested, submit proposals to IAIA. The deadline for Session Proposal submission is coming up quickly, June 30 of this year! The paper and poster abstract submission deadline will be the 31st of October.
Wes Fisher, of The Cadmus Group, and co-chair of IAIA’s Climate Change Section, provided the opening presentation, based on his report to the up-coming IAIA Climate Change Roundtable in Nagoya. He quickly reviewed the history of IAIA’s involvement in the topic over the past half dozen years, the increasingly central role that climate change is playing in considerations of planetary boundaries, and key issues that have emerged from on-going discussions within the Climate Change Section and the annual IAIA climate change roundtables. Climate change scientists and both governmental and private stakeholders are still relatively under-aware of the potential for EIA/SEA processes to contribute to addressing climate change challenges. So new and additional efforts are needed to reach out to and engage the climate science community and investment/risk managers. At the same time, effective applications of EIA/SEA and CEA tools and approaches to climate change decision-making processes need to be identified and highlighted, and opportunities for joint climate change and impact assessment need to be encouraged. (See IAIA CC and IA Follow-Up Next Steps, Draft, 15 April 2016, for discussion at IAIA-16).
With this background, brief presentations of recent experience and post-Paris strategies of their respective agencies were provided by:
Hilary Hoagland-Grey, IDB
Sameer Akbar, World Bank
Charles E. Di Leva, World Bank
Vladimir Stenek, IFC
Stephen Parsons, ExIm Bank
Douglas Mason, MCC
CCIA is integral to the thinking of each of these agencies, and several – IDB, World Bank, and IFC – are in the process of up-dating their environmental and/or climate change guidance. The World Bank has just, in mid-April, released its new Climate Action Plan, committing to major efforts on both mitigation and adaptation. ExIm’s efforts have focused on appropriate consideration of new coal-fired power plant investments. MCC works pro-actively with other federal agencies in screening activities for climate risks, while relying on its environmental and social assessment procedures and building climate change adaptation and mitigation into programs where possible.
Several members of WAB and the Climate Change Section have been considering the possibility of a follow-up symposium in Washington to the 2010 event. There was good discussion of the costs and resources that were needed for the 2010 event, and the need to assure that follow up and sponsorship efforts are addressed. There was general agreement that near-term efforts will necessarily focus on the IAIA ’17 conference.
Climate Change and Impact Assessment will surely continue to evolve as an interest of WAB/IAIA members. New tools and guidelines related to climate change will provide opportunities for future WAB presentations and Climate Change Session webinars. For now, some of the key references used or mentioned during the May 4th meeting are listed below.
IAIA CC and IA Follow-Up Next Steps, Draft, 15 April 2016, for discussion at IAIA-16
The Climate Change Symposia Proceedings:
IAIA CLIMATE CHANGE SYMPOSIUM, Washington, DC, USA / 15-16 November 2010 http://conferences.iaia.org/washingtonDC2010/
IAIA Climate Change Section – IAIA Connect
World Bank Group, Climate Change Knowledge Portal
World Bank Group, Climate Change Action Plan http://www.worldbank.org/en/news/infographic/2016/04/07/the-world-bank-group-climate-change-action-plan
WB CC & Safeguards Policy Review - Expert Focus Group, Mexico City, April 2013 https://consultations.worldbank.org/Data/hub/files/meetings/Safeguards_Focus_Group_ClimateChange_MexicoCity_Summary_Final.pdf
IFC Climate Implementation Plan (April 2016):
MCC’s initiatives in Climate Change:
USAID Environment and Global Climate Change
US Government Executive Orders and Policies
Another reference mentioned during the event is the IFC Good Practice Handbook – Cumulative Impact Assessment and Management: Guidance for the Private Sector in Emerging Markets:
7 January 2016
Challenges and Solutions of Addressing Environmental and Social Issues in the Wind Power Sector – Updates, Experience, and Revised EHS Guidelines
In addition to reviewing recent experience from on-going assessments of wind power projects in Central and South America, this two-hour session focused on lessons learned and advances in good industry practice, including key changes in the recently updated IFC’s Wind Energy EHS Guidelines, and the biological basis for bird and bat monitoring protocols.
Justin Pooley and Lori Anna Conzo summarized the changes made in the recently updated World Bank Group EHS Guidelines for Wind Energy in their presentation: EHS Guidelines Update - Wind Energy.
Lori Anna Conzo is a Senior Environmental Specialist and Biodiversity Focal Point in the Environment, Social and Governance (ESG) Department of the International Finance Corporation (IFC). As Biodiversity Focal Point, Lori works across the regions and sectors on biodiversity-related issues, with a focus on the infrastructures and renewable energy.
Justin Pooley is a Principal Specialist in IFC’s Environment, Social & Governance Department and the department’s global sector lead for power projects. Justin has worked on wind projects in multiple regions and was one of the core IFC team involved in updating the WBG Wind Energy EHS Guidelines in 2014-15.
Marianela González reviewed the field experience and results of field monitoring of bird and bat impacts of several wind power projects in Central America in her presentation: Bird and Bat Monitoring: Experiences from a Private Wind Power Producer.
Marianela González is Environmental and Social Compliance Coordinator at Globeleq Mesoamerica Energy. She has nearly a decade of experience in environmental and social management of renewable energy projects, including compliance with local legislation and IFC’s / MIGA’s Environmental & Social Performance Standards and Good International Industry Practices for wind and solar energy projects in Costa Rica, Panama, Nicaragua, Honduras, Guatemala, Mexico, and Chile.
Genevieve Beaulac presented very recent findings from IDB wind power projects in Oaxaca, Mexico, and Latin America – following up on her September 2014 WAB presentation, Wind Energy in Latin America, Challenges and Solutions.
Genevieve Beaulac is a Senior Environmental Specialist at the Environmental Safeguards Unit of the IDB, responsible for the design, implementation and monitoring of projects in the energy sector (wind, geothermal, hydroelectric and transmission lines.
Caleb Gordon reviewed broad data and biological theory in his presentation: Wind-Wildlife Issues in Latin America – Biological Perspectives.
Caleb Gordon, an ornithologist and wildlife ecology with WEST, Inc., has managed wildlife research and impact studies for IFIs and private developers on energy projects in Uzbekistan, Honduras, Costa Rica, Mexico, and Nicaragua.
Caleb has particular interest in offshore wind-wildlife studies. In this area, he has managed four large research projects for the Bureau of Ocean Energy Management (BOEM, USDOI), has given numerous presentations at scientific, government, and commercial conferences, and has served as wildlife issues subcommittee chair of the American Wind Energy Association’s (AWEA) Offshore Wind Workgroup (OWWG).
7 October 2015
Assessment of Biodiversity, Critical Habitat, and Ecosystem Services – Recent Experience from Africa and Latin America, with Reference to the IFC Performance Standards
Raymi Beltran of IFC, and Charles Hernick of The Cadmus Group, jointly presented their recent work in Assessment of Biodiversity, Critical Habitat, and Ecosystem Services – Recent Experience from Africa and Latin America, with Reference to the IFC Performance Standards.
Raymi Beltran is a Senior Environmental Specialists with IFC's Oil, Gas and Mining Group. He has over 15 years of experience in environmental and social management working on oil, gas, mining and infrastructure projects in Latin America, Asia and Africa. As part of his current position, Raymi works closely with private sector companies in assuring compliance with IFC's Environmental & Social Performance Standards and adopting Good International Industry Practices for their projects. Prior to joining IFC, Raymi was the Environmental Manager for Kinross Gold based in Santiago, Chile, and prior to this, he was the Environmental and Community Affairs Manager for the PERU LNG Project in Peru.
Charles Hernick is a Senior Associate at The Cadmus Group, Inc. He is an expert on USAID environmental safeguards/compliance and tropical forestry and biodiversity assessments. His recent projects include environmental impact assessments and tropical forestry/biodiversity assessments in Latin America, the Caribbean, and Africa. He has managed extensive policy and environmental finance research, and he designed the U.S. policy for mitigating the financial risks associated with the geologic sequestration of carbon dioxide (i.e., polluter pays principle/financial assurance).
13 May 2015
“Challenges to Performing ESIA and Implementing Projects in Liberia” – Presentation by Heather Boyd, Acorn International, LLC, and Wassim Hamdan, Earthtime.
28 January 2015
Ongoing Developments in Satellite Remote Sensing for Environmental and Social Impact Assessment: focussed on new technology solutions and how they can contribute to impact assessment and monitoring.
Referenced material is found at the following links:
Branches are responsible for their operating structure and activities, and operate separately and independently of IAIA. IAIA is not responsible or liable for the actions or activities of the Branches.